![]() |
Active Topics Memberlist Calendar Search |
Old Forum |
|
Advertisement: |
| World Politics | |
| |
|
| Page of 7 Next >> |
| Author | Message |
|
Israeli_Avatar
Guest Group
Joined: 08 August 2007 Online Status: Offline Posts: 34 |
Topic: An open letter to ’the world"Posted: 08 August 2007 at 7:12am |
|
Even though I do not agree with Kahane in totality, I think that he makes some very interesting points. Those that have an open mind and those that judge wisely and slowly should consider what he is saying, even though he was an extremist. I think that if all preconcieved notions are torn asunder and disregarded, one can adress something in a clear and logical manner, while at the same time taking into consideration impartial and open-minded historical analyses. An open letter to 'the world'
|
|
IP Logged |
|
|
herjihad
Senior Member
Joined: 26 January 2005 Location: United States Online Status: Offline Posts: 2473 |
Posted: 08 August 2007 at 9:52am |
|
Originally posted by Israeli_Avatar
Even though I do not agree with Kahane in totality, I think that he makes some very interesting points. Those that have an open mind and those that judge wisely and slowly should consider what he is saying, even though he was an extremist. I think that if all preconcieved notions are torn asunder and disregarded, one can adress something in a clear and logical manner, while at the same time taking into consideration impartial and open-minded historical analyses. An open letter to 'the world'
Salaamu Alaykum, The truth of the matter is the opposite of what kahane has presented and you have agreed with. The Phalasteenee had land they owned and lived on for hundreds of years, even thousands for some. The foreign invasion of the Zionists has driven them into extreme poverty where they once were wealthy with all they needed for food, shelter, and living at peace with their God, whether they were Jew, Muslim, Christian or atheist. These statements are so silly and implausible! What did the faces of the Zionist invaders look like as they massacered entire villages of defenseless citizens? What do the faces of the soldiers and settlers look like as they bully, harass, bulldoze, imprison and torment the remnants of the Phalasteeneeyeen? They have twisted, angry faces calling for blood and call the Phalasteeneeyeen the niggers of the Arab world. What did you think? They calmly and peacefully took their guns and tanks and bulldozers out and said in quiet voices: Don't be alarmed. Be calm. We are going to kill you all now. Leave, run if you can. We don't mind. Just don't come back, and don't tell anyone the truth about our massacres, Okay? ------------------------------------------ Kahane's words are not a genuine point of view. They are lies and propoganda. The Zionists came; they massacred; they conquered, and they rule with an iron fist and team of bulldozers, fighter planes, and tanks provided by the United States Government and her people. And as always we need to remember not to hate any but the oppressors. Many Jews and Israeli Zion lovers hate the massacres and the oppression and fight it as much as they can. When we let hatred blind us to truths, good and bad, the evil in this world win. Peace |
|
|
Al-Hamdulillah (From a Married Muslimah) La Howla Wa La Quwata Illa BiLLah - There is no Effort or Power except with Allah's Will.
|
|
IP Logged |
|
|
rami
Male Islam Senior Member
Senior Member Joined: 01 March 2000 Online Status: Offline Posts: 2550 |
Posted: 08 August 2007 at 9:57am |
|
Bi ismillahir rahmanir raheem
The Balfour deceleration predates all these dates and shows an established and long running campaign by the jews to take Palestine from the Palestinians. what he speaks of according to what little i know where backlashes against the jewish communities that at the time where clearly trying to steal land, jews that had no direct/blood lineage to the original jewish people in the roman times. This is clear and rational thought, jews who already lived there in peace with the arabs apposed the state of Israel. Islamicly speaking no massacre is justifiable for any reason not even in a valid jihad. |
|
|
Rasul Allah (sallah llahu alaihi wa sallam) said: "Whoever knows himself, knows his Lord" and whoever knows his Lord has been given His gnosis and nearness.
|
|
IP Logged |
|
|
Israeli_Avatar
Guest Group
Joined: 08 August 2007 Online Status: Offline Posts: 34 |
Posted: 08 August 2007 at 11:15am |
|
I will analyze the whole of your reply. Salaamu Alaykum, The truth of the matter is the opposite of what kahane has presented and you have agreed with. First of all, I did not make any statements of approbation, do not take what I have stated out of context, and do not my manipulate my words. "The truth of the matter" is more complicated than it seems, and it is never "the opposite" of anything, but a variation of that something intertwined with differential conjectures, analyses, and ideas that may just turn out to be a matter of perception that is reasonable than anything periphreal. The Phalasteenee had land they owned and lived on for hundreds of years, even thousands for some. The "Phalastenee" did not have anything as far ownership is concerned, that area of land was controlled by the Turks, or Ottomon Empire. If you were educated properly maybe then you would take it upon yourself to read before speaking. Also, the "Phalasteenee" were not just Muslims, they were also Jews and Christians. Over half a million Jews lived in "Palestine" before the state of Israel was even an idea. Additionally, the Muslim "Palestinians" of today could not have been their thousands of years, Islam is only about 1500 years old, and the Turks conquered that area in about the 12th century. What do the "Palestinians" have to do with anything? The word Palestinian or Filastin, as the country is called in Arabic, is not Palestinian‑Arab in origin (the Arabs of the region rarely used it before 1948) but refers to the biblical "Philistines," whose name the ancient Romans gave to the country in an attempt to obliterate the Jews' connection to it, and even this designation created by the Romans did not have any direct connection to the Palestinians. The contemporary Palestinian people are just a dialect of a larger sorrounding group that subsumed many other nationalities, and civilzations, a group that was ruled by the Turks, British, and the French before 1948, and a group that never really had their own unified nation, but were composed of conglomerations of tribes, some of which are Bedouins, and some actually serve in the Israeli army. Also, ownership was not emphasized by Kahane, he merely spoke of murders, you are changing the subject. If you are trying to say that sand is more imporant than humanity then you need a serious brain transplant. The foreign invasion of the Zionists has driven them into extreme poverty where they once were wealthy with all they needed for food, shelter, and living at peace with their God, whether they were Jew, Muslim, Christian or atheist. Actually, they or the Mulslim Arabs who you think are the Palestinians, were in extreme poverty before the "Zionists" were ever there, and when the "Zionists" came, the land was revitilized, and many Arab buisnesses began to prosper. Their poverty was caused by Islamic rule, and Ottomon tax demands, demands that ecologically devasted "Palestine" because taxes were demanded for every tree that was in the ground,and many trees were obviously removed. This was the Ottomon way of capitilizing off the destruction of mother nature. These statements are so silly and implausible! What did the faces of the Zionist invaders look like as they massacered entire villages of defenseless citizens? Hypothetically speaking, they probably looked, in this imaginary situation, like the faces of your brethren at a Hamas demonstration, or the Arab actors on your telivision networks that pretend to be Jews, and try to make ugly faces. What do the faces of the soldiers and settlers look like as they bully, harass, bulldoze, imprison and torment the remnants of the Phalasteeneeyeen? What do the faces of your brothers look like when they yell "Allah Akbar" and blow themselves up, and kill innocent Israeli children? They have twisted, angry faces calling for blood and call the Phalasteeneeyeen the niggers of the Arab world. What did you think? They calmly and peacefully took their guns and tanks and bulldozers out and said in quiet voices: Don't be alarmed. Be calm. We are going to kill you all now. Leave, run if you can. We don't mind. Just don't come back, and don't tell anyone the truth about our massacres, Okay? Forgive me, but were you involved in these massacres because you seem to have first hand knowledge of this? Are you one of the "niggers" that the Israelies left alone so you could perpetuate the "truth" of the "Israeli evil" all over the world, and your imaginary saintliness, and propriety in times of war? Kahane's words are not a genuine point of view. They are lies and propoganda. The Zionists came; they massacred; they conquered, and they rule with an iron fist and team of bulldozers, fighter planes, and tanks provided by the United States Government and her people. Your words are obviously the most genuine, that is exactly why you protest the idea of Islam being a violent religion with violence, and treat your women like filthy dogs. Who are these Zionists? What is the definition of that word? To most Arabs a "zionist" and a Jew is a synonymous term, please clarify what you mean. I must admit that certain "Zionists" acted unethically, but did you ever take a look in the mirror at your own reflection before you label the "Zionists" evil, or animalistic? Let's say, for the sake of argument, that these "Zionists rule with an Iron fist," so what then does the Taliban do? What does Iran do? Do they rule with a wooden penus? Or maybe a suicide bomb and an ak-47? If you are going to hold the "Zionists" up to a certain standard, I expect you to do that for everybody. After all, you are an educated and inteligent individual. And as always we need to remember not to hate any but the oppressors. Many Jews and Israeli Zion lovers hate the massacres and the oppression and fight it as much as they can. Who is this "we" that you speak of? I am definately not a part of this "we," nor am I your oppressor, I respect you like a brother, and I wish that we could live as a single entity in serenity. We are after all cousins, as tradition dictates. "Many Jews and Israeli Zion lovers" do fight "the oppresion." They fight the oppresion of the Jewish people and western society that has become prey to your uneducated oligarchs and tyrants that want to consume the world in a ball of fire, and bring everybody back to the middle ages, a time when the Islamic civilization was thought to be the most glorious, even though that was a time when your people were involved more so with science than religious propoganda, and nonsensical-contradictory and anti-semetic philosophy. When we let hatred blind us to truths, good and bad, the evil in this world win. That is something I agree with, Amen. Peace
Edited by Israeli_Avatar |
|
IP Logged |
|
|
Israeli_Avatar
Guest Group
Joined: 08 August 2007 Online Status: Offline Posts: 34 |
Posted: 08 August 2007 at 11:30am |
|
The Balfour deceleration predates all these dates and shows an established and long running campaign by the jews to take Palestine from the Palestinians. what he speaks of according to what little i know where backlashes against the jewish communities that at the time where clearly trying to steal land, jews that had no direct/blood lineage to the original jewish people in the roman times. Palestinians weren't just Mulsims, some of them were also Jewish and Christians so why would they try to steal land from themselves? They were a part of this sociopolitical enviroment, and did not need to make any claims because of their historical right, the oppresion and suffering caused by Muslim Palestinians, and because of their living side by side with these same Muslim Palestinians for hundreds of years. And what exactly did those Muslim Palestinians know of our lineage? And how were those Jewish Palestinians trying to steal land if they already lived side by side with these same people before the creation of the state of Israel? Are you saying that a Muslim has more right to that land than a Jew, and are you saying that these Palestinian murders conducted research on Jewish lineage before they murdered them? What is the source for your observations, that they were killed because they were trying to take land? Maybe they were used as a scapegoat and a mechanism of displacement as they were in Morrocco and Egypt. For the sake of argument, let's say they were trying to steal land. How do you justify the murder of women and children by suggesting that they stole land? How would children be able to steal land? How do you superimpose material things over people? What about the Jews that the Arabs killed? Were those Jews in peace with the Arabs because they were resting with the ground? Actually, the only Jews that opposed the creation of the State of Israel in 1948 were the religious, the same people your telivision networks denounce, castigate, and degrade. Tell that to the Palestians, Syrians, Iraqis, Iranians, and Saudis. Maybe they will listen to you, you are one of their brothers. Salam |
|
IP Logged |
|
|
Israfil
Senior Member
Joined: 08 September 2003 Online Status: Offline Posts: 3984 |
Posted: 08 August 2007 at 7:51pm |
|
|
IP Logged |
|
|
Israfil
Senior Member
Joined: 08 September 2003 Online Status: Offline Posts: 3984 |
Posted: 08 August 2007 at 8:01pm |
|
Israeli Avatar, Just to quench my curiousity can you provide tangible evidence that Israeli is not a racist state and extends rights to "all individuals" no matter their religion, race or creed? Can you also provide tangible evidence (aside from personal opinion) that the current massacre of the Palestinians is a solution to root out terrorism? One last thing..... Can you also provide evidence of a strategy provided by Israel to create some kind of middle east peace where the Palestinians can have their own state without the fear of being exterminated? Bulldozing homes of Palestinians and calling it justice is not a solution and frankly, it is not even justice. I'm sure there are Palestinians that do harbor criminals but they do so because they really don't like Israel not because they support their actions. Similarly we cops face this on the streets everyday. Many neighborhoods where neighbors are very "nosy" harbor criminals who ahve committed serious crimes (even murders). When we caught a criminal in a neighbors house we asked them: "Why did you harbor a criminal?" They told us "We don't like cops." I'm very critical of both states because both Palestinians and Israelis are to blame for their own mess but I believe personally that Israel, because of their capability is being too aggressive and too fanatical with their agenda to root out terrorism. I'm awaiting for someone who lives in that region (or has good knowledge of the current situation) to show me tangible proof that their side is right. |
|
IP Logged |
|
|
herjihad
Senior Member
Joined: 26 January 2005 Location: United States Online Status: Offline Posts: 2473 |
Posted: 09 August 2007 at 5:17am |
|
Salaamu Alaykum, I won't analyze the whole of your reply. However, a couple of quick points from a busy Muslim mom: The Phalasteeneeyeen were mostly wealthy in the wealth of the abundance that their beautiful land provided, and still does, just to their oppressors and not them. I read Exodus by Uris and the lies it perpetrated. The Jews, Christians, Muslims and others lived mostly peaceful, happy lives, especially compared to what their lives are like after the Zionist invasion supported at first by those who wished to rid their countries of the Jews they hated. And believe me if I had the time and energy I might insult you in return, but it is against the rules of this forum to do so, so I suggest you desist from it. And these ideas and thoughts all came from the beautiful brain that my Loving Lord has provided me with. Al-Hamdulilah. Allahu Akbar! Just to be clear or hopefully so, I love Jews and Muslims and Christians and yes, even atheists, who are decent people who respect and care for others lives and property and don't make excuses to massacre, ignore, or marginalize human suffering. My distress and sadness encompasses the Jews and Christians and atheists as well as Muslims who suffer under the Zionist racist occupation of Phalasteen. Islaam was the first and will be the last religion. We submit our hearts, minds, bodies and souls to Allah, the Ubiquitous.
Originally posted by Israeli_Avatar I will analyze the whole of your reply. Salaamu Alaykum, The truth of the matter is the opposite of what kahane has presented and you have agreed with. First of all, I did not make any statements of approbation, do not take what I have stated out of context, and do my manipulate my words. "The truth of the matter" is more complicated than it seems, and it is never "the opposite" of anything, but a variation of that something intertwined with differential conjectures, analyses, and ideas that may just turn out to be a matter of perception that is reasonable than anything periphreal. The Phalasteenee had land they owned and lived on for hundreds of years, even thousands for some. The "Phalastenee" did not have anything as far ownership is concerned, that area of land was controlled by the Turks, or Ottomon Empire. If you were educated properly maybe then you would take it upon yourself to read before speaking. Also, the "Phalasteenee" were not just Muslims, they were also Jews and Christians. Over half a million Jews lived in "Palestine" before the state of Israel was even an idea. Additionally, the Muslim "Palestinians" of today could not have been their thousands of years, Islam is only about 1500 years old, and the Turks conquered that area in about the 12th century. What do the "Palestinians" have to do with anything? The word Palestinian or Filastin, as the country is called in Arabic, is not Palestinian‑Arab in origin (the Arabs of the region rarely used it before 1948) but refers to the biblical "Philistines," whose name the ancient Romans gave to the country in an attempt to obliterate the Jews' connection to it, and even this designation created by the Romans did not have any direct connection to the Palestinians. The contemporary Palestinian people are just a dialect of a larger sorrounding group that subsumed many other nationalities, and civilzations, a group that was ruled by the Turks, British, and the French before 1948, and a group that never really had their own unified nation, but were composed of conglomerations of tribes, some of which are Bedouins, and some actually serve in the Israeli army. Also, ownership was not emphasized by Kahane, he merely spoke of murders, you are changing the subject. If you are trying to say that sand is more imporant than humanity then you need a serious brain transplant. The foreign invasion of the Zionists has driven them into extreme poverty where they once were wealthy with all they needed for food, shelter, and living at peace with their God, whether they were Jew, Muslim, Christian or atheist. Actually, they or the Mulslim Arabs who you think are the Palestinians, were in extreme poverty before the "Zionists" were ever there, and when the "Zionists" came, the land was revitilized, and many Arab buisnesses began to prosper. Their poverty was caused by Islamic rule, and Ottomon tax demands, demands that ecologically devasted "Palestine" because taxes were demanded for every tree that was in the ground,and many trees were obviously removed. This was the Ottomon way of capitilizing off the destruction of mother nature. These statements are so silly and implausible! What did the faces of the Zionist invaders look like as they massacered entire villages of defenseless citizens? Hypothetically speaking, they probably looked, in this imaginary situation, like the faces of your brethren at a Hamas demonstration, or the Arab actors on your telivision networks that pretend to be Jews, and try to make ugly faces. What do the faces of the soldiers and settlers look like as they bully, harass, bulldoze, imprison and torment the remnants of the Phalasteeneeyeen? What do the faces of your brothers look like when they yell "Allah Akbar" and blow themselves up, and kill innocent Israeli children? They have twisted, angry faces calling for blood and call the Phalasteeneeyeen the niggers of the Arab world. What did you think? They calmly and peacefully took their guns and tanks and bulldozers out and said in quiet voices: Don't be alarmed. Be calm. We are going to kill you all now. Leave, run if you can. We don't mind. Just don't come back, and don't tell anyone the truth about our massacres, Okay? Forgive me, but were you involved in these massacres because you seem to have first hand knowledge of this? Are you one of the "niggers" that the Israelies left alone so you could perpetuate the "truth" of the "Israeli evil" all over the world, and your imaginary saintliness, and propriety in times of war? Kahane's words are not a genuine point of view. They are lies and propoganda. The Zionists came; they massacred; they conquered, and they rule with an iron fist and team of bulldozers, fighter planes, and tanks provided by the United States Government and her people. Your words are obviously the most genuine, that is exactly why you protest the idea of Islam being a violent religion with violence, and treat your women like filthy dogs. Who are these Zionists? What is the definition of that word? To most Arabs a "zionist" and a Jew is a synonymous term, please clarify what you mean. I must admit that certain "Zionists" acted unethically, but did you ever take a look in the mirror at your own reflection before you label the "Zionists" evil, or animalistic? Let's say, for the sake of argument, that these "Zionists rule with an Iron fist," so what then does the Taliban do? What does Iran do? Do they rule with a wooden penus? Or maybe a suicide bomb and an ak-47? If you are going to hold the "Zionists" up to a certain standard, I expect you to do that for everybody. After all, you are an educated and inteligent individual. And as always we need to remember not to hate any but the oppressors. Many Jews and Israeli Zion lovers hate the massacres and the oppression and fight it as much as they can. Who is this "we" that you speak of? I am definately not a part of this "we," nor am I your oppressor, I respect you like a brother, and I wish that we could live as a single entity in serenity. We are after all cousins, as tradition dictates. "Many Jews and Israeli Zion lovers" do fight "the oppresion." They fight the oppresion of the Jewish people and western society that has become prey to your uneducated oligarchs and tyrants that want to consume the world in a ball of fire, and bring everybody back to the middle ages, a time when the Islamic civilization was thought to be the most glorious, even though that was a time when your people were involved more so with science than religious propoganda, and nonsensical-contradictory and anti-semetic philosophy. When we let hatred blind us to truths, good and bad, the evil in this world win. That is something I agree with, Amen. Peace
Edited by herjihad |
|
|
Al-Hamdulillah (From a Married Muslimah) La Howla Wa La Quwata Illa BiLLah - There is no Effort or Power except with Allah's Will.
|
|
IP Logged |
|
| Page of 7 Next >> |
|
||
Forum Jump |
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot create polls in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum |
|
Note: The 99 names of Allah avatars are courtesy of www.arthafez.com
Advertisement: