His Use of False Quotations and Other Dishonest
Tactics to Prove that Allah is a Moon-god
Adapted from the book
Common Questions People Ask About Islam
by Shabir Ally
Dr. Robert Morey proves in his book that Allah is the name of the moon god worshipped in Arabia before Islam. Is he right?
The book you refer to is entitled The Islamic Invasion: Confronting the World's Fastest Growing Religion .1 The author, Dr. Robert Morey, sees Islam as an invasion
into North America and a threat to his religious heritage. Unfortunately, Dr. Morey has resorted to dishonest tactics in combatting Islam. To prove his contention that Allah is not the God of Christians and Jews, he quoted from several books in such a dishonest fashion that the quotations say the opposite of what we find in those books .2
Dr. Morey quoted from the Encyclopedia
Britannica to support his case. But in fact the Encyclopedia says: "Allah is the standard Arabic word for
"God" and is used by Arab Christians as well as by Muslims" (Britannica,
1990 Edition, vol. 1, p. 276). Dr. Morey
also quoted from H.A.R Gibb to support his case. But Gibb actually says the opposite. In
his book Mohammedanism, Gibb says on page 26 that both Muhammad and his opponents believed
in "the existence of a supreme God Allah." Gibb further explained this on pages
37-38.3 Dr. Morey should have checked his references more carefully before his book went
Dr. Morey said that Alfred Guillaume agrees with
him, and he refers to page 7 of Alfred Guillaume's book entitled Islam. But here is what
Alfred Guillaume actually says on page 7 of his book: "In Arabia Allah was known from Christian and Jewish sources as the one
God, and there can be no doubt whatever that he was known to the pagan Arabs of Mecca as
the supreme being ".4 How could Dr.
Morey misquote like this? Dr. Morey quoted from page 28 of a book by another non-Muslim writer Caesar Farah. But when we refer to that book we find that Dr. Morey gave only a Partial quotation which leaves out the main discussion. The book actually says that the God who was called Il by the Babylonians and El by the Israelites was called ilah, al-ilah, and eventually Allah in Arabia .5 Farah, says further on page 31 that before Islam the pagans had already believed that Allah is the supreme deity.
Of course they had 360 idols, but, contrary to Dr. Morey's assertion, Allah was never one of the 360 idols. As Caesar Farah points out on page 56, the prophet Muhammad, on whom be peace, personally destroyed those idols. Dr. Morey also quoted from William Montgomery Watt. But Watt says on page 26 of his book that the Arabic word Allah is similar to the Greek term ho theos which we know is the way God is referred to in the New Testament .6
Dr. Morey quoted from Kenneth Cragg's book
entitled The Call of the Minaret. However, on page 36
of Kenneth Cragg's book we find the following: "Since both Christian and Muslim faiths believe in One supreme sovereign Creator-God, they are obviously referring when they speak of Him, under whateverterms, to the same Being."7
Further on the same page, Cragg explains that the One whom the Muslims call Allah is the same One whom the Christians call `the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ', although the two faiths understand Him differently.
Dr. Morey should know that as a scholar he has the academic obligation to quote honestly. He should also know that as a follower of Jesus, on whom be peace, he has an obligation to speak the truth.
1. Published by Harvest House Publishers, Oregon, US, 1992.
2. See quotations on pp. 47-53 of Dr. Morey's book.
3. See Mohammedanism by H.A.R. Gibb, Oxford University Press, 1969.
4. See Islam by Alfred Guillaume, Penguin, 1956, p. 7.
5. See Islam: Beliefs and Observances, by Caesar Farah, Barren's Educational Series, 4th Edition,
6. See Muhammad; Prophet and Statesman by William Montgomery Watt, Oxford University Press, 1964, p. 26.
7. The Call of the Minaret by Kenneth Cragg, Oxford University Press, 1964, p. 36.
Islamic Information &
Da'wa Centre International
For Recorded Message call: (416) 534-8657
E-Mail: [email protected]
Listen to Radio Broadcast 100.7 FM
Saturdays 7.00 a.m to 7.30 a.m
957 Dovercourt Road, Toronto, Ontario,
Canada M6H 2X6
Tel: (416) 536-8433 Fax : (416) 516-1543